register for free
View our sister sites
Our sister sites
Our sister sites
Our sister sites
Azz
Administrator
Azz is offline  
Location: South Wales, UK
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 18,577
Male 
 
10-12-2013, 03:58 PM

Philosophical discussion - is a clone of you, you?

Had an interesting discussion earlier - is a clone of you, really you?

My viewpoint is that no, it is not - the clone may well be a genetically identical human with a copy of your memories (not unlike twins at birth) but you are separate entities.

The simplest way I can support my viewpoint is this: if you were to die, and the clone continued to live, you personally, would not see/hear/share/know about anything the clone does (because you are biologically dead). The clone's life may well continue, but it is just that - the clone's life, a life that undoubtedly has links to yours, but the clone's life nonetheless.

What do you think?
Reply With Quote
moetmum
Dogsey Veteran
moetmum is offline  
Location: Hampshire, UK
Joined: Mar 2008
Posts: 3,481
Female 
 
10-12-2013, 04:11 PM
A clone would be genetically identical but would be a person in their own right.
Reply With Quote
Imana-Banana
Dogsey Senior
Imana-Banana is offline  
Location: Hatfield, UK
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 941
Female 
 
10-12-2013, 04:19 PM
It would only be you if it was born at the same time as you and had the exact same life experiences, in other words if it lived your life. If it was born 5 minutes later it's entire existence would be different and all it's brain synapses and neurons and all those other things that fire every time we move and speak etc would all have taken different pathways making you a new you altogether........

My brain hurts
Reply With Quote
Malka
Dogsey Veteran
Malka is offline  
Location: Somewhere
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 18,088
Female  Diamond Supporter 
 
10-12-2013, 04:21 PM
Even identical twins with identical DNA, brought up in exactly the same way are not the same as each other. So how can clones be?
Reply With Quote
Imana-Banana
Dogsey Senior
Imana-Banana is offline  
Location: Hatfield, UK
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 941
Female 
 
10-12-2013, 04:55 PM
Originally Posted by Malka View Post
Even identical twins with identical DNA, brought up in exactly the same way are not the same as each other. So how can clones be?
They aren't brought up exactly the same though are they, if you think about it they do a lot of things independently, they will wake and sleep differently, cry at different times, interact at different time, all those subtle differences as small as they are will make a difference to the way the brain develops ultimately leading to different personalities..

How many times can you put the word different in one post I ask myself
Reply With Quote
Tang
Dogsey Veteran
Tang is offline  
Location: Pyla Village, Larnaka, Cyprus
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 14,788
Female 
 
10-12-2013, 05:15 PM
Originally Posted by Imana-Banana View Post
They aren't brought up exactly the same though are they, if you think about it they do a lot of things independently, they will wake and sleep differently, cry at different times, interact at different time, all those subtle differences as small as they are will make a difference to the way the brain develops ultimately leading to different personalities..

How many times can you put the word different in one post I ask myself
No more than clones could possibly be 'brought up the same way' exactly. Think about it. Every action in their life would have to occur at the same time exactly carried out by the same person or thing exactly.

So it's not unreasonable to liken it to identical twins. Or think 'nature vs nurture'.

As humans haven't been cloned, but animals have, it is relative to have a look at myths and misunderstandings about cloning animals

http://www.fda.gov/animalveterinary/.../ucm055512.htm

I don't have that much more to add as I don't think the question has been phrased very well for 'debating' it has been phrased as if the 'clone' would appear at the same age you are now (clones are created as newborns). But also don't think there's all that much to debate about it. It's a YES or NO answer.

My answer to the question would it be 'me' is NO. It would be a human who would grow up to look very much like me in all respects (not even identical twins look EXACTLY the same as each other) but it would not be 'me'.
Reply With Quote
Imana-Banana
Dogsey Senior
Imana-Banana is offline  
Location: Hatfield, UK
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 941
Female 
 
10-12-2013, 05:25 PM
that's what I mean, they would have to be brought up exactly to the millisecond, so in theory it could be you, but in reality it never would be
Reply With Quote
Tang
Dogsey Veteran
Tang is offline  
Location: Pyla Village, Larnaka, Cyprus
Joined: Sep 2008
Posts: 14,788
Female 
 
10-12-2013, 05:28 PM
Originally Posted by Imana-Banana View Post
that's what I mean, they would have to be brought up exactly to the millisecond, so in theory it could be you, but in reality it never would be
Well the question was asked if 'you were cloned'. So that would only hold if you were cloned at the split second of birth. Ergo not much different from identical twins.

Now I am off to contemplate my belly button and ponder on the concept of 'self'.

Reply With Quote
Malka
Dogsey Veteran
Malka is offline  
Location: Somewhere
Joined: Apr 2011
Posts: 18,088
Female  Diamond Supporter 
 
10-12-2013, 05:29 PM
Originally Posted by Imana-Banana View Post
They aren't brought up exactly the same though are they, if you think about it they do a lot of things independently, they will wake and sleep differently, cry at different times, interact at different time, all those subtle differences as small as they are will make a difference to the way the brain develops ultimately leading to different personalities..
As my twin and I are fraternal and not identical, even though we definitely were brought up exactly the same way you are absolutely correct. Apparently [and according to old photographs that I have] I walked at 10 months whereas my twin just sat and expected me to go and fetch whatever she wanted. And she not only grew up with the "gimmees" but somehow my daughter grew up to be almost identical to my twin, also with the "gimmees".

It actually got to the stage where neither Mother nor I knew who we were talking to at times, calling my twin by my daughter's name, and her by my twin's name, and when my daughter was in her teens there were many times that I did not know whether I was talking to my twin or to my daughter.

Originally Posted by Imana-Banana View Post
How many times can you put the word different in one post I ask myself
Am I supposed to count them?
Reply With Quote
Fernsmum
Dogsey Veteran
Fernsmum is offline  
Location: Scotland
Joined: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,773
Female 
 
10-12-2013, 05:48 PM
I don't think a clone would be you because although genetically the same their personality would be different .
Reply With Quote
Reply
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Clone Or Not To Clone Gemini54 General Dog Chat 11 27-06-2013 07:20 AM
Clone Or Not Clone Gemini54 General Dog Chat 10 21-06-2013 12:52 PM
Would you clone your dog? vincegraff General Dog Chat 15 15-03-2013 09:34 AM
Would you clone your dog? Azz General Dog Chat 31 15-05-2009 11:08 AM
would you clone your dog? MistyBlue General Dog Chat 21 16-02-2008 03:22 PM

© Copyright 2016, Dogsey   Contact Us - Dogsey - Top Contact us | Archive | Privacy | Terms of use | Top