Yes i loved brenda, I like andy but i didnt think he was giving it 100%. Brenda has alway given 150% to her performances and she has fun

I agree.... even Andy looked surprised when he was kept in! He had more criticism tonight, too, from the judges.....
Little Louie was in tears over Brenda. What a brave performance she put on, singing after the decision was made, a poigniant song too, a very professional performance. Her music is not what I would go out and buy as I have a different taste but I sincerely hope she gets a recording contract and goes from strength to strength.

My vote for the winner is also Shayne. He has the mass market appeal, and what a lovely smile too.

I like Andy, I wanted Journey South to go!
In SCD I am glad Zoe got through!

I like Journey South......

I am so sad Brenda's gone but glad Shayne is still there..

I am in love with Shayne he can be my toyboy anyday and can sing to me

Mini ....... but he hasn't got a beard

he can soon grow one !

No surprise who left in Celebrity CD - but was amazed Brenda left XF

On programmes like X Factor and Pop Idol I usually have one person who I really want to win, but I haven't this time round. I like all the finalists but I'd like Andy to win it really... I don't think that Shane really needs to win the competition, he's got a huge career ahead of him no matter what I reckon.

Thought it would be Journey South they are so like dozens of other duos or Andy who only seems to do well with the old songs. Sorry Brenda has gone, mind you I probably will not watch anymore now she has so at least I have got some time back.