register for free
View our sister sites
Our sister sites
Our sister sites
Our sister sites
SBT
Dogsey Junior
SBT is offline  
Location: Essex, UK
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 204
Male 
 
10-03-2007, 03:57 PM
Here are some breeds that I think may be what they would fight if there were no APT's
American Bandogge
- English Bull Terrier
- American Bulldog
- Presa Canario
- Bully Kutta
- Fila Brasileiro
Reply With Quote
Meg
Supervisor
Meg is offline  
Location: Dogsey and Worcestershire
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 49,483
Female  Diamond Supporter 
 
10-03-2007, 03:59 PM
Originally Posted by HayleySBT
Minihaha, Im having to defend a breed that is in danger more than most breeds to a global mod on a big forum world wide. If i get heated, passionate its because i love this breed and do not want to see anymore damage come to it, if i dont follow the rules or guidelines to this forum, then Mods/Admin/Members im very sorry, but my love and passion for Bull breeds will not be pushed aside to rules and I wont sit by and allow people to discriminate and damage the breed any further than it has already, Just like i wouldnt sit back if there was a racist attack on this forum and go oh i better no saying anything due to rules, I have not personally attacked you, nor have i swore or been rude too you, im simply defending myself agaisnt you, and more importantly defending a fantastic canine god of all breeds which has bad press and many killed for no reason but looks.
My fight for Bull Breeds does not just happen on Dogsey, but off the internet and on other forums.
There is no human aggression minihaha in the pit bull so there is no need to breed this out. Just because I voice what i believe to be correct, Im not the only person on this forum or or stafford owner who believe like I do, but i will speak my honest mind. In the Stafford and Pit Bull there is no human aggression,if so then i its not true to its spirit and therefor should be pts.[B] I dont want have a a stafford that is not true to its correct spirit. Its up to us owners to understand, control and respect it.
So lets try not to get off topic Minihaha and get back to Pitbulls.
Originally Posted by Hayley
Pitbulls are not a dangerous breed of dog, they can be dangerous compared to a smaller less powerful breeds,
....errrm and isn't that what most of us have been saying ?

Hayley to me the content of some of your posts is very confused, over dramatic and defensives against people who have merely expressed their opinions which is what the debate is about , did you read the opening post and the bit about empty comments ?.
It seems there are a lot of threads leading to this at the moment, so better to have it one place.
Do you think Pit Bull Terriers (The ones that are banned in the UK and many other places) are dangerous? IF SO SAY WHY.
Do you think they are not dangerous? IF SO SAY WHY.
Before getting involved in the discussion, please make sure your first post in this thread makes your position clear on the topic.
ONLY take part in this discussion if you are willing to provide reasons to back up your views, we don't want any empty comments, but a proper discussion.
Most of us here have stated our opinions clearly and concisely and produced data to back up our views, if you don't agree that is fine but could you please try to say why you disagree without all the dramatics?

Hayley what do you mean when you say above 'dogs being true to their correct spirit' the signature on all your posts states
Originally Posted by HayleySBT
How can you truly love your breed when all you do is try and change it, Because if you did truely love your breed you would not want to change any aspect of it..
does this mean if you truly love PBTs you will not try to change them and breed out aggression be it dog to dog or dog to human?
Reply With Quote
Nicci_L
Almost a Veteran
Nicci_L is offline  
Location: UK
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 1,415
Female 
 
10-03-2007, 04:01 PM
Originally Posted by SBT View Post
If there were no more pit bulls in the UK or even the world lets say the become extinct, the vile people who enjoy dog fighting would choose another breed would we then ban that one.
Thats hypothetically speaking the Pit Bull is more than likely the most famous historical breed of all time partly due to it's history there are four other banned breeds on the list and to be perfectly honest, with events that have taken place over the last few months, thats where they need to stay to protect them from the most vile people on the planet. Say if they were to lift the breed bans on the DDA the Pit Bull Terrier would soon be overtaking the Stafford in rescue centres across the UK..Is this what you all want to see? Dogs handed in because people have bitten off more than they can chew, which quite frankly is what is happening to the Stafford right across the UK, everyday another one or two or even three handed in, where will the madness stop?
There are already other breeds people use for fighting if people do not happen to get their grubby hands on a Pit Bull many people whom work in rescue probably see those dogs dumped everyday, we do not need more breeds adding to the list, I think we should all be happy with what we have and concentrate on keeping our dogs that are perfectly legal off it.
Reply With Quote
Meg
Supervisor
Meg is offline  
Location: Dogsey and Worcestershire
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 49,483
Female  Diamond Supporter 
 
10-03-2007, 04:35 PM
Originally Posted by pod View Post
It's not the dogs' fault that they have high within species aggression. They are just responding to their environment and expression of their genes in the only way they know how. The factors that control the aggression, namely breeding and environment, are almost entirely under human control.

It could be that in the USA there has been selective breeding to improve temperament, with enough of a sub population to reform the breed with less aggression. But I don't see this as a possibilty in the UK, where there is legislation against their ownership and where they are more likely to have been bred for the wrong reasons.

I don't think it sad at all if these poor, abused dogs no longer exist, and I don't mean they should be put to sleep for no valid reason, just that they should no longer be bred.
Originally Posted by Nicci_L View Post
I would even go as far as stating that any Bully or Mastiff breed is not a breed for everyone, yes they look awfully nice as puppies infact many of the larger breeds with heavy wrinkle look so cute when they are young (herein more than likely lies the problem) people have to see past this and look at the bigger picture because a lot of the Bully and Mastiff breeds are specialist, not dangerous, just specialist, every one of them is unique, has different traits and every one of these breeds needs a certain type of owner/handler some need to be more experienced than others, some breeds really are not for the first timer. But I do understand that everyone has to start somewhere if they choose a dog as a pet.
I think the best possible thing that could happen for the Pit Bull in the UK is to stay on that ban list (I'm probably going to get slated for that, but I really don't care) it's already a victim of it's own success the torture these dogs suffer is appauling and it needs to be stamped out worldwide, not the dogs, just the suffering for them and until that suffering is eradicated there is no future for the Pit Bull
Originally Posted by Mahooli View Post
And that's what I tried to say at the beginning. The breed is better off banned here to prevent the terrible abuse it goes through.
Becky
It is good to see some really honest opinions and a measure of this forum that you all feel able to express them here many have told me they share your views but are reluctant to say so .


I feel sick when I see the videos posted about PBT, ironically they are frequently posted by those who do not wish to see any action taken to prevent such cruelty and torture,( sorry, I don't mean everyone who posts the videos) one has to wonder if some of these people secretly support dog fighting.


There can be few fates more horrific for an intelligent and brave dog like a PBT than being confined and kept for fighting, or trained to be a weapon and used against humans. The people who do this sort of thing can have no love for dogs, the poor creatures must have the most terrible existence, is it any wonder some of them are aggressive and dangerous . I would rather a dog was dead than in pain .

I don't want to see the ban on the entry to this country lifted on some breeds like PBT, if the ban prevents the perpetuation of a terrible sport and saves just a few dogs it is a necessary evil.

I don't see other breeds taking over from the PBT( except perhaps some of the other breeds that are banned if they were allowed entry to this country), they don't have the same mystique attached to them.
Reply With Quote
pod
Dogsey Veteran
pod is offline  
Location: UK
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,558
Female 
 
10-03-2007, 04:39 PM
Originally Posted by SBT View Post
Is the Pitbull is only in existence because of the sport of dog fighting, like pod has said


During the mid-1800s, immigration to the United States from Ireland and England brought an influx of these dogs to America, mainly to Boston, where they were bred to be larger and stockier, working as farm dogs in the West as much as fighting dogs in the cities. The resulting breed, also called the American Pit Bull Terrier, became known as an "all-American" dog. Pit bull type dogs became popular as family pets for citizens who were not involved in dog-fighting or farming. In the early 1900s they began to appear in films, one of the more famous examples being Pete the Pup from the Our Gang shorts (later known as The Little Rascals).

During World War I the breed's widespread popularity led to its being featured on pro-American propaganda posters.

I don't think so


Huntsville, Alabama police raided a dog-fighting arena on Feb 28, 2002 and seized 10 Pit Bulls. The city's attempt to legally euthanize four pit bull puppies, never trained to fight, was stopped by Madison County Circuit Court Judge Joe Battle, who ruled that the pit bull puppies were not dangerous by virtue of their genetics alone (AP Wire; Apr 6, 2002).

Huntsville appealed to the Alabama Supreme Court, which affirmed (City of Huntsville v. Sheila Tack et al., 1010459, S.C. Alabama; Aug 30, 2002) the Circuit Court opinion by a 6-2 vote; the written dissent addressed procedural matters of legal status of the parties, not the nature of the dogs. The puppies were adopted.
SBT, I'm not disputing that the breed has also seved as a companion in some instances but the fact remains that it has been developed as a fighting dog, the reason for it's existence....hence the name PIT.

Could I ask SBT that you please follow the rules of Dogsey by using quotes and referencing when you use text lifted from webpages. Thanks
Reply With Quote
pod
Dogsey Veteran
pod is offline  
Location: UK
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 1,558
Female 
 
10-03-2007, 04:52 PM
Originally Posted by Minihaha View Post
I feel sick when I see the videos posted about PBT, ironically they are frequently posted by those who do not wish to see any action taken to prevent such cruelty and torture,( sorry, I don't mean everyone who posts the videos) one has to wonder if some of these people secretly support dog fighting.
Mini, I'm so glad you've said this. I've had the same thoughts and I'm so relieved to see it's not just me. This is the reason I've felt a bit alienated from Dogsey lately.
Reply With Quote
Hayley SBT
Dogsey Veteran
Hayley SBT is offline  
Location: south west
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 7,399
Female 
 
10-03-2007, 05:42 PM
I give up, ive tried my best to say how i feel which I have done, i wont go around in circles.
Pitbulls are not dangerous, they can be but so can every breed of dog, and Nicci if you support the Pitbull being banned you support the DDA, so there for i cannot take part in the debate anymore, and what makes this worse you are a Bull Breed owner, never thought from every post you have made on my forums and other and your own you supported the pit bull being banned.

My ending statement is

American Pit Bull Terrier as not dangerous.
Reply With Quote
kristian
Dogsey Senior
kristian is offline  
Location: s,wales
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 254
Male 
 
10-03-2007, 05:42 PM
Originally Posted by Minihaha
I feel sick when I see the videos posted about PBT, ironically they are frequently posted by those who do not wish to see any action taken to prevent such cruelty and torture,( sorry, I don't mean everyone who posts the videos) one has to wonder if some of these people secretly support dog fighting

i hope this isn't aimed at me! because my video posts just show the dogs for what they are! and i absolutley am dead against dog fighting i think the people who fight dogs should be put in the ring with something like a lion and see how they like it! it just frustrates me the way the media put these dogs accross!
Reply With Quote
Meg
Supervisor
Meg is offline  
Location: Dogsey and Worcestershire
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 49,483
Female  Diamond Supporter 
 
10-03-2007, 05:48 PM
Originally Posted by Hayley SBT View Post
My ending statement is
American Pit Bull Terrier as not dangerous.
Hayley could you please answer my guestion,you have avoided doing so and some of us are waiting to know.. what do you mean when you say above 'dogs being true to their correct spirit' the signature on all your posts states
Quote:
Originally Posted by HayleySBT
How can you truly love your breed when all you do is try and change it, Because if you did truely love your breed you would not want to change any aspect of it
..are you saying if you truly love PBTs you will not try to change them, in other words you will not try to breed out aggression and that goes for dog to dog not just dog to human aggession ?

Reply With Quote
Hayley SBT
Dogsey Veteran
Hayley SBT is offline  
Location: south west
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 7,399
Female 
 
10-03-2007, 05:54 PM
I do not own an American Pit Bull Terrier minihaha, but I own Staffords, so I can only comment on their spirit as I know and love it.

The Stafford Spirit is, Bold, Fearless, reliable, loving, loyal and great with humans.
Would i change anything of that No. I have never owned or own a pit bull so there for i cannot comment.

But I do wish Minihaha you WOULD STOP with this Human aggression you keep saying the Pit Bull has as its not true, dont you think that they have enough to contend with?
And if you are trying to draw it out of me in such a sly way Minihaha, just for you I DO NOT CONDONE OR SUPPORT DOG FIGHTING.
..are you saying if you truly love PBTs you will not try to change them and breed out aggression be it dog to dog or dog to human?
Reply With Quote
Reply
Page 17 of 132 « First < 7 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 27 67 117 > Last »


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 3 (0 members and 3 guests)
 


© Copyright 2016, Dogsey   Contact Us - Dogsey - Top Contact us | Archive | Privacy | Terms of use | Top