Honest opinions please.....

If you are asking if this dog is too thin? Then i would say it is.

Yes, sorry didn't want to put words into peoples mouths, btw its two different dogs

Yes they are to thin, who's are they and what are they being fed on?

That looks terrible, is she ill, or half starved, poor thing

Undernourised - too much rib showing IMO - how old are they?

At the time they were both 11months, if they were being fed at all I do not know what it was on they no longer look like this they were rescued and have been rehomed. I ask the question because someone had said they could see no wrong with this.

Well who ever said these dogs where alright looking like this must be mad. Alot of Owners of these type of dog keep them athletic looking but these 2 are to thin to fall into that catagory,in my opinion.

I certainly wouldn't be happy to see a dog looking like this - if they were eating I would be concerned they had an illness which was resulting them being so thin!

The only reason I asked their age was I know that youngsters can take a while to put the weight on but initial look is they have been starved.

Oh my they look awful, sorry if thats abit harsh but I'd be rather concerned if I saw someone with a dog that thin