|
Location: Dogsey and Worcestershire
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 49,483
|
|
Originally Posted by Ian
And is it not irresponsible to take an illegal dog, knowing that it could be taken from you and destroyed?
I've no doubt at all that some of these owners love their dogs... but they could just as easy have loved a dog of any breed..
Not suggesting they are "terrible" people... and not suggesting that we should take them out back and beat them with a stick either...
but regardless to whether it's done in ignorance or not.. they simply are "IRRESPONSIBLE" if they take on a banned dog and/or a dog they have no knowledge of or done no research into... and when something terrible happens should we sit back and say "awww wasn't her fault, she's/he's not a terrible person, she/he just didn't know... poor thing"
Exactly Ian. Also in this country at least, any good breeder of a bull breed or any rescue would not allow a dog to go to an unsuitable owner. If a person obtains any dog be it from a breeder or a rescue it will surely have documentation of some kind, if not a pedigree at least some details related to it and its origins, so people can't really can't say they don't know what they own . Surely the only people who don't have documentation are those who obtained their dogs from dubious sources and are well aware of the type of dog they own.
Originally Posted by Stamford
I think that a Pit-bull definitely needs the right kind of owner,but I believe all dogs need the right kind of owner.But in the case of
any of the so called big strong breeds they all need a firm but fair handler/owner and one that needs to be totally responsible for and understand the animal that they are in control of.
..and what if they don't get the right kind of owner Stamford, PBT are not even supposed to be around in this country and those that are certainly don't seem to attract the right owner.
If image and breed traits are not the main criteria for people owning these particular dogs,why do people have them. There is plenty of choice, why a PBT,why don't they get a dog that doesn't resembles a banned dog in any way, why not buy a good Staffy from a good breeder or a get a staff cross from a rescue. I doubt very much that the dog which killed Ellie came from either.
Yes other breeds need a 'certain type' of owner and in the wrong hands can cause problems. Under socialised incorrectly treated dogs of any breed can exhibit a number of behaviours, some become destructive of their environment/excessively vocal/withdrawn/have OCDs, others become aggressive to other dogs/humans or both. I think the traits for which a breed was originally bred predispose them to certain behaviours and this also applies at times of stress. I have already mentioned the freeze/flight or fight responses, if a stressful situation that a dog couldn't cope with arose many breeds would freeze or flee , PBT would almost certainly fight, a trait for which they were bred.
I think some people are missing the point here or deliberately choosing to misunderstand what others are saying often because they don't bother to read the whole thread.
I don't think anyone has said that
all Pit Bulls are dangerous, just that because of the traits for which they were originally bred they have the potential to do more damage than many other breeds therefore some of them are dangerous and more so than other breeds.