nope the dog would live as long as not ill that the vet said to PTS then only then. sorry no friend would as that of me.

Absolutely 100% agree with Hali.

As a true animal-lover I couldn't comprehend why they would want a healthy dog PTS No, I certainly wouldn't carry out those wishes.

No question would keep the dog, especially as a)I am an animal lover b)the dog knows me c)the dog is healthy

However I would like to think that if my friend trusted me enough to be that involved in things she/he would trust me enough to ensure their dog was healthy happy and safe

I would do exactly as she wishes,she trusted you you shouldnt let her down she is waiting for her dog

Save the dog definitely!

OMG competely save the dog...although i would never tell her that i wouldnt as she may appoint someone else to do that and then the dog would be PTS!

Then if i met her again i would give her what for!

No friend of mine would ask it as they would know my answer. I would keep the dog. They couldn't accept that, they'd have to find another executor.

Same here, no-one who knows me would ask this. I can't even kill a spider

I'd save the dog....I'd have the row with her after we met over the other side

the only way that i would allow the dog PTS was if it was a dog that for example - only responded to the owner, and was only controllable by the owner, and if it was extremely old and infirm and i felt that it would be kinder to PTS than feel the loss of its human companion.

However as none of these have been given as possibilities in this scenario - i would save the dog !!!