|
Location: Usually in a muddy field somewhere
Joined: Nov 2004
Posts: 20,145
|
|
Originally Posted by
Labman
I have consistently warned people that if a dog is left in the crate all day it must have a mid day break. If you work with their body, withholding food and water while in the crate and not giving them room for much activity, they do fine. Others doing the same and I have very good records turning out happy, well adjusted dogs. I suspect the OP will see she can't live up to the extreme, unrealistic, unnecessary standards of the majority here and disappear just like all the rest.
Apart from the obvious that has already been pointed out (regarding the manner in which Labman crates puppies/dogs and the amount of time that they are crated), I despair at the blanket approach Labman adopts. He promotes this 'method' to everyone, mostly with absolutely no idea of the circumstances of each indivudual dog. How thoroughly irresponsible.
For instance, it could be very dangerous to leave my dog crated alone because he is a severe epileptic. If he were to have a cluster of fits while trapped in a crate, he would be at risk of injury from paws/jaws/claws/teeth becoming trapped between the bars. There would be no water available for him to drink, meaning that he would quickly become dehydrated (a common cause for the epileptic dog to have to be hospitalised on a drip), no quick snack for him to eat after the fit when he is ravenous and his energy levels depleted and he would tear himself raw during the post-ictal period, where the need to pace around is so overwhelming that he would crash around within the confines of the crate.
I know this for a fact because we did get a crate, hoping it would help during the post-ictal period. Naturally, when he did have a fit in the crate, we had not left him alone in the crate, nor had we shut him in, so we were able to get him out to safety - even though this meant crawling in there with him and getting scratched by his flailing paws. And he did injure himself during the post-ictal period but again, we were there to help him out.
Young puppies, having been removed from mother and litter mates can be anxious for a while and placed in a stark, unfurnished crate could pant, jump up at the mesh, cry and become dehydrated when there is no water to drink. If you are away for 5 hours, how can you possibly know just how dehydrated that puppy has become?
Labman - if you intend to continue to push yourself as a major expert in all things dog, it is incumbent upon you to advise responsibly.