BARF/Burns/Nature's Choice/Home Cooked

I'm in a quandry about the merits of these four diets and wonder if any of you have any comments. I am currently feeding commercial kibble + a home cooked meal of protein, veg, brown rice and fruit. All the above diets claim similar benefits to the dog but BARF is so different to the others.

I want a diet that has less residue and I want it to be as natural as possible. I'm really worried about bone splinters on BARF and there are so many for and against arguments on the web I am totally confused.

Do you have any comments/experience of these?

I feed BARF and have done for about 6 months.Wouldn't go back now..the boys look GREEAT and enjoy their food do much more than before.Waste production is minimal,solid ansd less smelly.
I find it cheaper and as long as bones are not cooked they won't splinter
Nikki

I've now been feeding BARF for about 4 weeks.
Both dogs LOVE it! I've had no problem with any sort of splinters - as the bones are raw, therefore softer than cooked bones.
They also both hardly poo as much, and when they do, it's always solid.

Im seriously thinking about feeding my next pup BARF! need to do some reading up, sounds complicated!

I feed my dog Burns and he's looking fantastic on it. He doesn't poo as much as he used to and they are a lot harder so easier to clean

I thought it was complicated Gems, but now i've got into the routine, it's really easy!

I must admit I am getting pretty tempted.

I found a supplier online, they deliver fornightly.
I seperate the chicken wings into bags, weighing 2-4lbs, so all I have to do every day, is grab a bag and let it de-frost!

Kingsley still enjoys a bit of kibble (Gusto), but I won't let Teagan have any kibble at all.
I try to give her something slightly different every day (veggies, yoghurt, eggs etc).

With the chicken wings?

Yep, with the chicken wings.
But i'm going to slightly change it, as people say you shouldnt feed veggies with meat.
So i'm going to give her the non-meat products for her breakfast, and the wings and mince for her dinner.