register for free
View our sister sites
Our sister sites
Our sister sites
Our sister sites
Wolfie
Dogsey Veteran
Wolfie is offline  
Location: Kent
Joined: May 2004
Posts: 11,180
Female 
 
06-08-2004, 09:12 PM

Who gets the dog?

Crossposted

Animal Planet is 'casting' for a new 'reality' show called "Who Gets the Dog?".

Basically they pull a dog out of a shelter, shuffle it around for 3 days with 3 different families (24 hours each), and then somehow the dog is supposed to "pick" which family it wants to live with. The only safeguard it offers the dog is that "You must not have been CONVICTED (my caps) of (i) any crime that includes cruelty to animals, or (ii) any felony under any jurisdiction in the United States or any other Country. And "You must be ready, willing and able to adopt and care for the dog involved in the production of the series."

Here is the website:
http://www.lmnotv.com/whogetsthedog/

If you think that this is not the best thing to put a dog through for the sake of 'entertainment', please send a comment to them to let them know what a stupid idea this is and how inhumane it is to put a dog (particularly a shelter dog with who knows what having happened to end him up in a shelter in the first place) through this kind of stress and confusion. Can you imagine the health and behavior problems something like this could cause the "lucky dog", as they say on their website.

I wonder if they would do this to a four year old foster child. And we all know that it's not likely to be dog savvy people who would do this. What happens to the dog after the show and the novelty has worn off with the family "required" to adopt the dog? And not being "convicted" of an animal crime is little reassurance since most animal abusers are never caught, much less convicted.

Here is the form where you can let your feelings be known about this to Animal Planet at:
http://extweb.discovery.com/viewerrelations

Please spread the word.
Reply With Quote
Bon
Almost a Veteran
Bon is offline  
Location: N.B. Canada
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,282
 
10-08-2004, 12:09 PM
Thanks Wolfie I am going to send an email, how terrible for the dogs....what are they thinking.
Reply With Quote
Barbara
Dogsey Veteran
Barbara is offline  
Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,826
Female 
 
10-08-2004, 01:03 PM
They're thinking $$$$ as usual. I'm going to boycott Animal Planet. I never really liked the way some of those shows antagonized wild life, like Steve Irwin.
Reply With Quote
Jenny234
Dogsey Veteran
Jenny234 is offline  
Location: Surrey, UK
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 3,814
Female 
 
10-08-2004, 03:19 PM
thats so horrible! im not very good with the words, or else i would post a comment!! What did you lot write? i'll just reword what you wrote. Hopefully it will sound better than what i can put together!
Reply With Quote
Robert
Dogsey Senior
Robert is offline  
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 460
 
10-08-2004, 05:51 PM
Email done, plus suggestion for new show.

Take all the people who would appear in those type of shows or think them up, drop them off on an uninhabited island with out telephones or any means of communication with the outside world,, NO cameras, leave them there and forget about them
Reply With Quote
Bon
Almost a Veteran
Bon is offline  
Location: N.B. Canada
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,282
 
11-08-2004, 12:56 AM
I like that idea Robert
Reply With Quote
Bon
Almost a Veteran
Bon is offline  
Location: N.B. Canada
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,282
 
11-08-2004, 12:58 AM
Response from HSUS Re: New dog reality show
Crosposted Response from HSUS
** PERMISSION TO CROSSPOST **

Information about the Animal Planet show, "Who Gets the Dog,"

"we talk openly with Animal Planet about the fact that their
primary mission is to entertain, which can sometimes be in conflict
with advocacy or education."
.......

Hi. I wanted to provide some information about the Animal Planet
show,"Who Gets the Dog," that might be helpful and which, I hope,
will allay some of the concerns about the show. (Forgive this for
being kinda long, but I really want to give you as much info as I
can.)

The HSUS has worked closely with Animal Planet and with their
production company on the concept for the show, and on the pilot
episode. After reviewing the pilot, we're working with them on the
series. I, and my co-workers here, have all worked at shelters, so we
can appreciate concerns about stress on the dogs and the sincerity of
the applicants.

Please let me tell you what we all have put in place to make this the
best possible experience for all concerned. We helped develop an
application questionnaire for potential adopters that was modeled on
several very good shelter pre-adoption screening applications. We
provided Animal Planet and the production company with guidelines on
red flags that should be considered on initial interviews, but staff
at The HSUS review each and every application for milies/individuals
being considered for the show.

If we have questions, the people are reinterviewed and we're given
the updated information. So far, only a couple of the potential
adopters that made it as far as our review have been rejected by us,
so the production company is doing a good job of pre-screening
applicants and doing home visits. (It might be good to note that many
of the applicants are previous shelter adopters, or are already
looking at shelter/rescue dogs to adopt.)

Similarly, we provided Animal Planet and the production company with
guidelines on dog selection, and we also review each dog selected,
not just on his/her own merits, but also in the context of the
families who are being considered for that particular dog. The same
stuff a shelter/rescue group would do--for example, if there are kids
in the family, is this particular dog appropriate for the age,
activity level, etc.

A really critical part of selecting a dog who will be on the show is
for the shelter or rescue group to select a dog who will NOT be
unduly stressed by commotion, meeting a lot of people, having cameras
around, etc. The dog who was selected for the pilot (and that's the
only completed show I've seen so far)was a happy-go-lucky guy who
thought the whole process was one big play date.

I know from working at the shelter, when I would take dogs to appear
on tv, that there are dogs you can be pretty sure will react
positively to the whole event. It's the same with every shelter who
takes adoptable animals to events or adoption days--you don't take
the dog who's stressed everytime someone new walks by.

We trust the shelters/rescue groups to know their animals. The dogs
also stay with a foster person during the process so there's
continuity for the dog. If the right dog is selected, we don't think
he/she will be stressed from hanging out with a couple of different
families over a couple of days. The key is to have a confident,
friendly, easy-going dog.

And one of the most important things in the concept of the show is
that certain people make a connection with certain animals. That's
one of the things you could see clearly in the pilot show--the dog
really bonded with one over another. And that's what the panel of
experts is looking for--does the DOG have a preference for one of the
families. Because that's a big part of the decision. I should say
that the experts were also all approved by The HSUS, and we checked
with local groups as well, and include a trainer, vet (who works
with a local rescue groups as well), and a person who has worked with
a number of groups, knows dogs, and knows about adoptions.

I've said this before and I'll say it again--we talk openly with
Animal Planet about the fact that their primary mission is to
entertain, which can sometimes be in conflict with advocacy or
education. But we hope our involvement, and the involvement of a
broad
spectrum of shelters/rescue groups (all of whom, as you've pointed
out, have a choice about whether to participate) will help make this
a show that promotes the concept of adoption and carries important
messages about shelters/rescue groups.

When you consider that fewer than 20% of owned pets are adopted, it's
clearly important to bring a higher profile to the benefits of
adopting from a shelter/rescue group. If Who Gets The Dog makes it
trendy to go to a shelter instead of a pet store, we should all heave
a sigh of relief!

Through meeting the potential adopters and dogs, there will also be
opportunities in the show to discuss exactly the kinds of things you
suggest--why one family might make a better home for the particular
dog than another, the needs of the dog, etc. So...I hope this helps,
but if you have other questions or concerns, please feel free to
email me.

You may post this to any lists you're on if you think it's helpful,
and anyone can email me. Thanks for the opportunity to respond.

Kathy Bauch
Senior Director, Promotions and Advertising
The Humane Society of the United States
301-258-3060
fax 301-258-3074
-------------------------------------------------


http://members5.boardhost.com/Mestizo1/msg/18320.html
Reply With Quote
Barbara
Dogsey Veteran
Barbara is offline  
Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,826
Female 
 
11-08-2004, 05:50 AM
After reading that, it doesn't sound that bad, what do you think? Okay, I'm waiting for this response... :smt071 :smt075 :smt062
Reply With Quote
Bon
Almost a Veteran
Bon is offline  
Location: N.B. Canada
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,282
 
12-08-2004, 12:12 AM
I hate those reality shows with passion, what kind of person wants to go on TV show to get a dog anyway. I think it is cruel to make a dog choice between families and turn it into a TV program.
Reply With Quote
Barbara
Dogsey Veteran
Barbara is offline  
Location: Long Island, New York
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 1,826
Female 
 
12-08-2004, 12:26 AM
I'm not big on the reality tv shows or any other shows for that matter lately. It does sound like the dog can choose who they click with so that's why I thought maybe it wouldn't be so bad.
Reply With Quote
Reply
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 


© Copyright 2016, Dogsey   Contact Us - Dogsey - Top Contact us | Archive | Privacy | Terms of use | Top